← Back to News

Law Update

Case Law Updates — 19 November 2026

Fifteen reportable judgments across the 13 to 19 November 2026 upload window (Sunday 15 November excluded), with stragglers swept from 12 November — one from the Federal Constitutional Court, four from the Supreme Court, six from the Lahore High Court and four from the Sindh High Court (the Islamabad High Court returned no in-window entries for a fifth consecutive window).

Federal Constitutional Court of Pakistan

  • Capital Development Authority v. Maqbool Hussain — the second FCC judgment on CDA acquisitions in a fortnight, on Sectors C-13 to C-16: mere delay in satisfying an award neither moves the legally relevant valuation date fixed by section 30(1) read with section 2(k)(iii) nor enlarges the entitlement, though the Authority equally cannot invoke finality to evade payment; eligibility for built-up property benefits must be established at the date prescribed by the governing award, and satellite imagery and a commission’s report are evidentiary aids, not substitutes for adjudication. Leave granted; petitions converted into appeals and allowed to the extent indicated, the awards left operative subject to lawful variation.

Supreme Court of Pakistan

  • Mst. Meraj Bibi v. Mst. Zar Gula — a Larger Bench of five, resolving a long-standing conflict, lays down the “rule of the known overt act”: title vested by inheritance is never extinguished by lapse of time, and under Article 120 of the Limitation Act 1908 time runs only from the day an overt act repudiating the heir’s title is brought home to the heir’s knowledge, which is not to be inferred from a revenue entry alone; silence, inaction or delay never amount to waiver, relinquishment simpliciter is void, and a transferee takes no better title than the transferor had. Nine questions answered with directions under Article 187 to revenue, registering and settlement authorities; the law declared not to reopen any decree that has attained finality.
  • Inspector General of Police, Punjab v. Alamdar Hussain — the Punjab Service Tribunal has no power to review its own judgment: the powers of a civil court conferred by section 5 of the Punjab Service Tribunals Act 1974 are confined to deciding the appeal, review being a distinct remedy that must be expressly conferred, and on passing its appellate judgment the Tribunal becomes functus officio. Petition converted into appeal and allowed and the review order set aside (without prejudice to the reinstatement), the Court noting that review lies before the Federal, KP and Balochistan Tribunals but not the Punjab or Sindh Tribunals.
  • Attock Refinery v. Appellate Tribunal Inland Revenue — section 3(1) of the Sales Tax Act 1990 has three elements — a taxable supply, by a registered person, in the course or furtherance of a taxable activity — each to be examined in its own light, and the onus of establishing every ingredient of a taxing event lies on the State; where a process (here decanting and desalting of crude oil) was the supplier’s own contractual obligation, its performance is no service and the payment is in substance an adjustment of price. Leave petition converted into appeal and allowed; the demand set aside.
  • Ali Ahmad v. Additional District Judge, Sialkot — the mere pendency of a petition for leave to appeal does not suspend the running of limitation for execution of a decree under Article 181; on disposal by the court of last instance that decree becomes operative, time is excluded under section 15 only where execution is actually stayed, and the doctrine of merger applies only where leave is granted and the appeal allowed. Appeal allowed; the execution application dismissed as time-barred.

Lahore High Court

  • Commissioner Inland Revenue v. M/s Shoaib Traders — the department must follow the compulsory-registration procedure before charging sales tax under section 3, and the extended definition of “registered person” in section 2(25) cannot be read so as to impose a registered person’s entire liability retrospectively for the pre-registration period; the omission of section 19 by the Finance Act 2004 and the insertion of Rule 6(4), requiring compliance only from the date of compulsory registration, are decisive. Reference applications dismissed; the Tribunal’s orders maintained.
  • Mst. Nargis Khatoon v. Land Acquisition Collector — a single contiguous parcel acquired for one public purpose may not be bifurcated into frontage and rear portions and compensated at different rates; compensation under section 23 of the Land Acquisition Act 1894 rests on the collective potentiality and actual market value, not revenue classifications, and where neither party proves market value with precision the Court undertakes a judicial appraisal of the whole record. Appeal allowed; a uniform rate of Rs. 500,000 per marla assessed for the entire acquired land.
  • Zahid Bashir v. Senior Civil Judge — where a Rent Tribunal itself adjourns the proceedings on the tenant’s first appearance for the purpose of filing the application for leave to contest, the tenant cannot be held to have filed it out of time under section 22(2) of the Punjab Rented Premises Act 2009, the maxim actus curiae neminem gravabit applying and a provision attaching penal consequences being construed strictly; an order granting leave to contest is in any event interlocutory and outside the appeal under section 28. Petition dismissed.
  • Habib Ullah v. Additional District Judge — the exclusion in section 2(a) of the Punjab Rented Premises Act 2009 is confined to premises where religious worship is actually performed, so ownership by a Waqf estate or application of rental income to religious purposes does not bring an ancillary commercial shop within it; and a duly authorised Mutawalli is a “landlord” under section 2(d) competent to institute ejectment proceedings though not the personal owner. Petition dismissed in limine.
  • Arslan Amjad v. Controller of Examinations — a candidate who failed to pass LL.B. Part-II within the prescribed chances cannot claim the benefit of a Part-III result card mistakenly issued to him: there is no estoppel against law, a provisional roll-number slip or result card confers no vested right, locus poenitentiae cures irregularity but not illegality and is unavailable against an illegal order, and the freedom of profession under Article 18 is subject to qualifications prescribed by law. Intra-court appeal dismissed.
  • Mst. Musarrat Muhammad Din v. Safdar Ali — interim relief restraining further alienation was rightly granted where the plaintiff’s capacity to contract is in issue: a binding contract requires free consent, an agreement of relinquishment without consideration is a nullity under section 25 of the Contract Act 1872, fraud vitiates the most solemn proceedings, and the loss of immovable property is always irreparable injury, especially where the transfer is said to be without consideration and founded on fraud. Petition dismissed; interim relief maintained.

Sindh High Court

  • M/s Indus Motor Company v. Federation of Pakistan — fiscal incentives notified under the Automotive Development Policy and given statutory effect were protected by section 6 of the Protection of Economic Reforms Act 1992, which attaches to any statutory order with a specified term and forbids its alteration to the investor’s disadvantage; a government that keeps its incentivising notification in force while contradicting it by a later SRO breaches that protection, and section 19(3) of the Customs Act 1969 is triggered only on an express withdrawal, which never occurred. Petitions allowed; the further levy of additional customs duty declared unlawful.
  • Ashraf Yar Khan v. High Court of Sindh — no sufficient cause was shown under section 5 of the Limitation Act 1908 for the delay in a service appeal, illness of counsel being no excuse absent proof that it prevented the step during the days of delay; and the plea that no limitation runs against a void order is narrow, reaching only an order that is a nullity for want of jurisdiction over subject matter or person, not an order of a competent authority said to be wrong in fact, law or procedure. Condonation refused; appeal dismissed as time-barred, with no expression on the merits.
  • M/s Marium International v. Federation of Pakistan — where no phytosanitary certificate was ever issued at the country of origin, a certificate issued at the country of re-export is not sufficient compliance with the import conditions: the Import Policy Order 2022 and Rule 57 of the Pakistan Plant Quarantine Rules 2019 require both certificates cumulatively, the origin certificate being the one that guards against pests at the place of growth, and an importer’s lack of knowledge that an origin certificate was fake bears only on any penal proceedings. Petition dismissed.
  • Muzamil Kartio v. Abdul Qadir Kartio — a plaintiff claiming derivative title must prove the title of his vendors, want of rebuttal being no proof; relief under section 39 of the Specific Relief Act 1877 presupposes that the instrument is before the Court and its holders are heard, so a court cannot cancel deeds it has not seen or whose holders are not impleaded, and an eighty-year-old entry in the record of rights prevails over a certificate of a negative fact whose author was never examined. Civil revision dismissed.

Download PDF